“ This place has THE BEST meatball subs. There's a reason they've been here for 40 years. The service is good and the food is really consistent! Just a good old pizza parlor often filled with little league kids after their games. Perfect for groups that want pizza and beer! ”

“ The staff is very friendly and they always remember what I order and how I want it made. The draft beer is always cold and comes in a full size pitcher. Come in and watch a game or two, grab a pizza, some wings and a pitcher of the beer of the day, you won't be disappointed. ”

“ Great tasting pizza, X-Large is a great price Great customer service. There is a good amount of space and 2 or 3 TVs to watch sports. Ample parking. ”

“ Took kinda long to get my order but it was well worth the wait! I would definitely recommend coming here! ”

“ Yea definitely one of the best pizzas I've had in the area. They put the right amount of cheese to tomato sauce ratio, most pizza places put way too much tomato sauce so the cheese slides off. The cheese on this pizza stuck on nicely. The cheese was cheesy, doesn't taste watered down. And the pepperoni was full of flavors. The pizza dough had the right amount of chew to it. I'll definitely be back to try other things on their menu and definitely recommend this place if you're looking for some good pizza in the area. It seems like they make everything fresh as well so that's a plus. ”

“ Really great pizza!! I love their pepperoni and italian sausage the most but overall great quality ingredients the cheese is good. I order here on weekends they close online ordering on regular weekdays lil earlier than their close. ”

“ More like a 3.5 but rounding up because of the great customer service from the dudes making the 'za and helping out the customers. Pizza Supreme is a staple of the community and has been here so long as I've had conscious memory of the area. From what I've heard waiting for our order, it seems like they're under new ownership or management, but the OG still comes by to help out. With the new changes they're also on Slice which I just learned is a pizza ordering app with rewards and deals and such. It's their online order system, but you can also order over the phone too. I ordered via the app and there was some wait, but it's understandable since it's dinner time and they make all their items fresh. Also the wait for our food was delayed a bit longer since they had to make the cheesy sticks as well and lots of people were ordering on the spot, over the phone, and through various delivery apps. The workers were super chill with it and even gave us a free soda to compensate for that. We got the: 1) Meat Lovers: -This is one of their specialty pizzas. -It comes with pepperoni, sausage, Canadian bacon, and salami. -For modifiers, we ordered a thin crispy crust, light sauce, and paid extra for mushrooms. -Unfortunately, we didn't check the pizza until we got home since we were hungry and in a bit of a hurry, but we ended up with OLIVES instead of mushrooms. This made our pizza a bit more bitter and my brother isn't a fan of olives in general. Sucks since it was an additional cost, but I guess it makes sense if the workers were drowning in orders. -Light sauce came with barely any sauce on it and it was just a less flavorful cheesy bread with less cheese and with meat on top. -We got this as a large since there was a lot of us, but, no offense, it was pretty mid and we have leftovers frozen for a desperate day in the future. 2) Cheesy Sticks: -Comes with the option of ranch or marinara and we opted for marinara. But knowing how tasty it is, I think it might even pair well with the bleu cheese that they have for their wings. -Nice and gooey and cheesy with the perfect amount of garlic and herb taste. -Even though this was the last item that they did their best to speedily finish, it turned out to be the MVP of the meal that increased their score for me. -We devoured these to be honest. In the future I think I'd check my order before leaving or at least reiterate it to the staff. That and order something else that won't be as much of a miss. ”

“ Great pizzas! I ordered the Supreme Pizza!! It's loaded with all the toppings! I love that their pizza marinara sauce isn't salty like chain pizza stores. Every ingredient tastes very fresh!! The pizza bread is soft and fluffy too!! The Spaghetti Pasta with Meatballs is ok. Not as flavorful as I would have liked. They prob used the same marinara sauce from the pizza to the spaghetti so when I tasted it, the spaghetti was very bland. However the meatballs had the flavor to bump the taste up. ”